Big Box vs. Contractor-Installed vs. DIY Aluminum Fencing

When it comes to choosing an aluminum fence, homeowners are often faced with three primary options: buying from a big box store, hiring a contractor, or purchasing a DIY Aluminum Fence kit from a wholesale supplier. While each method has its own set of benefits and drawbacks, the key to making the best choice lies in understanding how they differ in quality, cost, and long-term value.

In this guide, we’ll compare the pros and cons of big box, contractor-installed, and DIY aluminum fencing. By the end, you’ll see why choosing a wholesale aluminum fence supplier can save you money and deliver a superior product.

Big Box Aluminum Fencing

Big box stores like those big names you already know are often the go-to places for consumers looking for a quick and convenient fence solution. While they may seem cost-effective initially, there are several factors that make them less appealing for long-term investment.

Quality Concerns

Big box stores frequently source their aluminum fencing materials from overseas manufacturers, particularly from countries like China. These materials tend to be lower in quality, making the fences less durable and prone to damage over time. Unlike domestically produced aluminum, which adheres to stricter quality standards, imported options may lack the structural integrity needed for long-term use.

Lack of Guidance and Support

When you purchase from a big box retailer, you typically receive minimal guidance on installation, layout, or customization. The fencing panels are often sold in standardized sizes without customization options, which can be problematic if your yard has unique dimensions or terrain. You’re left to figure out the entire process on your own, which can lead to mistakes and additional costs.

Higher Overall Costs

Though the upfront price might be lower, the costs of replacing damaged sections or dealing with faulty installations can add up quickly. In the long run, investing in a higher-quality product from a trusted supplier is more economical.

Standardized Options

Selection is often limited to a few basic styles, lacking the customization that can be achieved through a wholesale supplier.

Contractor-Installed Aluminum Fencing

Hiring a professional contractor can seem like the safest bet, especially if you’re not comfortable with DIY projects. However, this method also comes with its own set of challenges.

Costly Labor Fees

The biggest drawback of contractor-installed fencing is the labor cost. Professional installation fees can significantly increase the overall expense, sometimes doubling or tripling the price compared to DIY options. You are essentially paying a premium for someone else’s labor when you could be doing it yourself with the right guidance.

Inconsistent Quality

While some contractors use high-quality materials, others may opt for cheaper options to maximize their profit. Even reputable contractors can sometimes cut corners, leaving you with a fence that doesn’t meet your expectations.

Limited Customization and Availability

Contractors often work with pre-determined fencing styles and sizes, giving you less control over the final look of your property. You may not have as much say in the layout or design compared to a DIY project, which can result in a fence that doesn’t fully meet your expectations. Additionally, coordinating with contractors can sometimes result in delays and misunderstandings. 

Finding a reliable contractor and scheduling the project can be time-consuming, especially during peak seasons.

DIY Aluminum Fencing with Wholesale Suppliers

Purchasing a DIY aluminum fence kit from a wholesale aluminum fence supplier combines the best of both worlds: affordability and quality.

One Kansas City customer shares: “I was looking for a cheaper way to get a fence for my dogs and Aluminum Fences Direct was a great option. Not only is their pricing reasonable, the whole transaction was easy and done online. Probably saved like $2K in having a contractor supply the fence. They were quick to answer questions and always communicated promptly.”

Made in the USA

Unlike big box stores that often import materials, Aluminum Fences Direct offers high-quality, domestically manufactured aluminum fences. These fences are built to withstand weathering and retain their aesthetic appeal for years, without the risk of rust or corrosion.

Cost Savings

By opting for a DIY installation, you can eliminate labor fees entirely. Wholesale prices ensure that you are paying only for the materials, allowing you to allocate your budget to higher-quality fence panels and accessories rather than expensive installation services. Overall, DIY installation can cut total expenses by up to 40% compared to hiring a contractor.

Professional Guidance for DIY Success

One of the biggest advantages of working with a DIY aluminum fence supplier is the support throughout the process. From planning your layout to guiding you through installation, they provide expert advice that ensures your project goes smoothly, helping you avoid common pitfalls. 

It couldn’t be easier – it all just starts with you (the homeowner) filling out the simple Layout Form so that in-house experts can get a feel for your space. From there, they can guide you through the ordering process so you know exactly what you need.

Customization and Flexibility

DIY aluminum fence kits offer the flexibility to adapt to your property’s unique needs. Whether your yard has slopes, curves, or specific design requirements, the customizable options from a wholesale supplier give you control over the final product. With a wide range of aluminum fence panel styles, colors, and accessories to match any landscape, giving you more flexibility in design.

Why Choose Aluminum Fences Direct?

Aluminum Fences Direct stands out as the go-to choice for DIY wholesale aluminum fencing because of its commitment to quality, affordability, and comprehensive support. Unlike big box stores that often source cheaper, lower-quality materials from overseas, AFD works only with local manufacturers that only use American extrusions in their aluminum fences, ensuring quality, superior durability and weather resistance.

One of the biggest advantages of choosing AFD is the transparency and value it offers. You won’t encounter hidden costs, surprise labor fees, or subpar materials. Instead, you’ll receive top-quality aluminum fence panels at wholesale prices, designed to last for decades. Plus, AFD provides personalized support, including detailed installation guides and expert advice to make your DIY project a success.

With AFD, you’re not just buying fencing; you’re investing in a durable, attractive solution that enhances your property’s value without breaking the bank. For more information on installation, visit our comprehensive DIY guide and explore fence style options here.

Making The Best Choice

While big box stores and contractor-installed fencing may seem appealing initially, they fall short when it comes to quality, cost, and customization. On the other hand, DIY aluminum fencing from a reputable wholesale supplier like Aluminum Fences Direct offers the perfect balance of affordability, durability, and expert guidance.

By choosing to DIY with quality materials from a trusted supplier, you gain more control over your project, save money, and achieve a professional-looking result without the hefty price tag. Start your aluminum fencing journey with Aluminum Fences Direct today, and see the difference for yourself.

Before buying an aluminum fence, have you considered the following?

➢ Top 5 things to avoid when installing your own aluminum fence

➢ Top 5 things to consider before purchasing an aluminum fence

Scroll to Top